Insecticide resistance is a major obstacle
to the control of agricultural and medical pests. Resistance is defined
by the World Health Organisation as " The development of an ability in
a strain of an organism to tolerate doses of toxicant, which would prove
lethal to a majority of individuals in a normal (susceptible) population
of the same species".
The development of resistance in insects to
acutely toxic insecticides generally occurs by selection of rare individuals
in a population that can survive the insecticide. It is pre-adaptive and
not a mutational effect. This implies that it is an inherited trait. Most
commercial insecticides are designed to be poor mutagens and their use
results in an intense chemical selection (high dose, high toxicity) which
is not conducive to genetic alterations, but allows survival of pre-adapted
(i.e. resistant) individuals. Insects
become resistant either: behaviorally (avoid exposure to a lethal dose)
or physiologically (find ways to survive a normally lethal dose).
Mosquito Insecticide Susceptibility
Studies in Grand Cayman 1965-1996
The susceptibility of Cayman mosquitoes to
various insecticides has been monitored for the past 30 years. The
most commonly employed testing was carried out by larval bioassay, in
which mosquito larvae (usually III or IV stage) are exposed to insecticides
of different concentration so that a dose mortality curve can be produced.
From this LD50 and LD90 values can be found.
The values for mosquitoes from different areas
of the island can then be compared and values from the same areas over
time, thus providing information on the overall resistance situation.
However, over a period of 30 years many
different staff and consultants have passed through MRCU and carried out
mosquito susceptibility tests. Consequently, many different protocols
and methodologies have been used making useful interpretation of results
difficult.
Insecticidal treatments by MRCU began in about
1965, initially using Malathion through vehicle mounted thermal fogging
equipment. Aerial applications began in the early 1970's and have continued
since. Currently ground space spray
application is carried out using Leco ULV application equipment and aerial
application is carried out using Micronair atomisers.
The chart above shows a summary of aerial applications carried out by
MRCU. It can be seen that Malathion was used up until 1974 after which
time it was discontinued due to detected resistance using larval bioassays.
From 1971 to 1994 naled (Dibrom) was employed, again its use being discontinued
due to elevated LD50 in larval bioassays.
Fenthion (Baytex) use was started in 1994. During the period 1971 - 1995
a range of different pyrethroid insecticides have been employed. However,
from 1995 to 1998 permethrin synergised with piperonyl butoxide has be
the pyrethroid of choice.